Retirement planning has become increasingly technical. The introduction of the two-pot retirement system, changes to contribution limits and adjustments to retirement thresholds mean that investors need to understand not only how much they have accumulated, but how each component of their retirement savings can be accessed, taxed and converted into income.
From experience, we know that the most important decisions arise at three distinct stages: in the years leading up to retirement, at the point of retirement, and once retirement income begins. Some decisions are strategic, others are irreversible, and almost all have consequences for tax, liquidity and the sustainability of future income.
Before retirement: Build efficiently and preserve carefully
Approved retirement funds remain among the most tax-efficient long-term investment vehicles available to South African investors, bearing in mind that contributions are deductible up to 27.5% of the greater of taxable income or remuneration, subject to an annual cap of R430 000 from 1 March 2026. Any excess contribution is carried forward and may be used in future tax years. Further, investment growth within these funds is also exempt from tax on interest, dividends and capital gains.
Over a long investment horizon, this tax treatment can materially enhance compounding – although the trade-off is that retirement funds are subject to Regulation 28, which limits exposure to certain asset classes and currently permits aggregate foreign exposure of up to 45%, including the 10% African allowance. While these limits reduce investment freedom, they are intended to prevent excessive concentration and encourage appropriate diversification. The two-pot retirement system, introduced on 1 September 2024, has added a further layer of complexity – and retirement savings are now broadly divided into three components:
- The vested component, which generally contains benefits accumulated before implementation, is adjusted for the once-off seed capital transferred to the savings component.
- The savings component, which receives one-third of future contributions.
- The retirement component, which receives the remaining two-thirds and must generally be preserved for retirement.
The savings component allows one withdrawal per tax year, subject to a minimum of R2 000 and the available balance – with withdrawals being taxed at the member’s marginal rate. Although this access can provide relief in a genuine emergency, note that it should not be treated as a routine source of cash. Remember, the cost is not limited to the tax paid on withdrawal. Capital removed from a retirement fund also loses its future tax-free growth, reducing the amount ultimately available to fund retirement.
Investors leaving an employer fund should be equally cautious in that resignation, retrenchment or dismissal may create withdrawal options – although it’s important to understand the different rules relating to the vested, savings and retirement components. A preservation fund can protect accumulated retirement capital while retaining certain access rights, but preservation withdrawals, savings component withdrawals and retirement lump sums are subject to different rules and tax tables.
At retirement: Understand what can be taken and what must be annuitised
At retirement, each component must be dealt with according to its own rules. The savings component may be taken in cash or transferred to an annuity, while the retirement component must be used to purchase a compulsory annuity, subject to the applicable de minimis threshold. The vested component is governed by the rules applying to those benefits, including any vested provident fund rights that arose before 1 March 2021.
Where a cash lump sum is available, the first R550 000 is currently tax-free – although keep in mind that this is a cumulative lifetime concession, not an amount available per fund. This means that previous retirement lump sums, withdrawal benefits and severance benefits can reduce the remaining tax-free amount. Having said that, keep in mind that cash commutation decisions should never be made in isolation. While taking cash may provide useful liquidity, it can also create an immediate tax liability and reduce the capital available to produce retirement income.
From 1 March 2026, the general annuitisation de minimis threshold increased to R360 000, although the precise calculation under the two-pot framework depends on the composition of the vested and retirement components. A living annuity may also be fully commuted where its value falls below R150 000.
At retirement: Choosing the right annuity
Once the available cash portion has been determined, the balance must be used to purchase either a guaranteed life annuity or a living annuity. A guaranteed life annuity transfers investment and longevity risk to an insurer in exchange for a contractual income – and can provide certainty and protect against the risk of outliving one’s capital. However, note that this decision is irreversible and the capital does not normally form part of the retiree’s estate.
On the other hand, a living annuity keeps the capital invested in the retiree’s name and allows an annual drawdown of between 2.5% and 17.5%. It provides investment flexibility and allows remaining capital to pass to nominated beneficiaries, although the retiree carries the investment and longevity risk. That said, the decision should not be based on flexibility alone – but rather on an assessment of essential income needs, other income sources, health, life expectancy, dependants, risk tolerance, estate planning objectives and future liquidity requirements.
It’s important to keep in mind that a living annuity can later be used to purchase a guaranteed annuity, but the reverse is not possible. This makes the initial annuity decision one of the most important and consequential choices made at retirement.
After retirement: Coordinate income, tax and liquidity
Once retirement begins, the focus invariably shifts from accumulation to ensuring sustainable income throughout retirement. The objective is not simply to generate the highest possible return, but to draw income in a manner that balances current needs with the preservation of capital. For living annuity investors, the annual drawdown rate is critical, as drawing too much too soon can permanently weaken the portfolio, particularly during periods of poor market performance. Importantly, income should also be drawn from the most appropriate source, keeping in mind that living annuity income is taxable as ordinary income, while discretionary investments may give rise to interest, dividends tax or capital gains tax. This means that the sequencing of withdrawals can affect both taxes and the longevity of the overall portfolio.
Discretionary investments are particularly important because they provide liquidity for large, irregular expenses such as home maintenance, vehicle replacement, travel, family support, medical costs or a move into a retirement village – and attempting to fund these expenses through higher living annuity drawdowns can disrupt the income strategy and increase tax.
It’s essential that the investment strategy is regularly reviewed to ensure that the drawdown rates are optimal, that the sequence of withdrawals is appropriate, and that the portfolio is exposed to sufficient growth assets to ensure that purchasing power is not being eroded. A sound retirement strategy connects the decisions made before retirement with those taken at retirement and the income strategy that follows. Tax rules change, markets move, spending patterns evolve, and personal circumstances shift – meaning that the plan needs to be reviewed regularly. While the two-pot system may have made retirement planning more complex, the underlying principle remains unchanged: retirement capital should be preserved where possible, accessed carefully and structured to support a sustainable income over the long term.
Have a brilliant day.
Sue