What to know before investing in a living annuity

One of the more common surprises we encounter in retirement planning is that many people spend their working lives contributing diligently to a retirement annuity, pension fund or provident fund, only to discover at retirement that they cannot simply take all the money in cash. Understandably, this can feel restrictive, particularly where someone has always viewed the accumulated capital as ‘their money’.

In reality, retirement funds are designed to help investors accumulate capital and then convert that capital into retirement income. In exchange for the favourable tax treatment of investor contributions during the accumulation years, access to the capital is limited to ensure a sustainable retirement income is derived from the capital. Generally speaking, when a member retires from a retirement fund, such as an RA, pension, provident or preservation fund, they may take up to one-third of their retirement capital as a lump sum, while the balance must be used to purchase an annuity. That said, keep in mind that withdrawal rules have become somewhat more nuanced following the two-pot retirement system and the harmonisation of provident fund rules, although the principle remains that retirement fund capital is intended primarily to provide retirement income.

What is a living annuity?

A living annuity is a post-retirement income vehicle into which compulsory retirement fund money can be transferred at retirement. Unlike a life annuity, where an insurer guarantees an income for life, a living annuity is market-linked and provides no guaranteed income. The retiree remains invested in underlying portfolios, draws an income from the capital, and carries the investment risk, inflation risk and longevity risk. While this flexibility makes living annuities attractive, it also introduces investment risk if not well managed. Living annuities permit the annuitant to select the underlying investment strategy, nominate beneficiaries, select their drawdown level, and review their income annually. However, if returns are poor, withdrawals are too high, or the annuitant lives longer than expected, the income can come under pressure. In our experience, living annuities should be viewed as retirement income vehicles rather than bank accounts or discretionary investments.

How the income works

Annuitants must draw an income each year within the prescribed range, which is currently between 2.5% and 17.5% of the living annuity value, calculated on the policy anniversary. This drawdown rate can generally be reviewed once per year, keeping in mind that the annuitant can select income to be paid monthly, quarterly, bi-annually or annually, depending on their circumstances. That said, it is important for annuitants to understand the limitations of such an investment vehicle. Notably, a living annuity does not allow unrestricted withdrawals from capital to fund vehicle purchases, home renovations or family emergencies, with the exception being if the value of the living annuity falls below the prescribed commutation threshold, in which case it may be possible to withdraw the remaining value as a lump sum, subject to tax.

This is important as many retirees do not fully realise that the compulsory portion of their retirement funds is effectively locked into an income structure. As such, it is essential that the cash decision at retirement be made in the context of debt, emergency funding, future expenses, tax and the income required from the annuity.

Choosing a sustainable drawdown

The rate at which the annuitant draws down is one of the most important decisions in living annuity planning. Importantly, while the rules allow annuitants to draw up to 17.5% per year, this does not mean that such a rate is sustainable. In fact, drawing at or near the maximum for any meaningful period will almost certainly erode capital. Living annuity income is funded from investment growth and capital, and if the drawdown rate is consistently lower than the long-term net return of the portfolio, there is a better chance of preserving the capital base. Conversely, if the drawdown rate consistently exceeds the return, the capital will reduce over time and the rand value of the income may come under pressure.

Remember, too, that retirees do not experience retirement in neat averages. Markets fluctuate, inflation is unpredictable, and spending needs change over time. This means that a retiree who draws down too heavily in the early years of retirement, particularly during a period of poor market performance, may cause lasting damage to the portfolio. In practice, the drawdown decision should be made in the context of the full retirement plan, taking into account age, health, spouse’s income, discretionary investments, future expenses, tax position, investment time horizon and estate planning considerations.

Investment, tax and beneficiaries

Because a living annuity remains invested, the underlying investment strategy is central to the sustainability of the income. While a portfolio that is too conservatively invested may feel safe, it can leave the annuitant exposed to inflation and insufficient long-term growth. Conversely, a portfolio that is too aggressive may expose the retiree to uncomfortable volatility, especially where income is being drawn monthly.

From a tax perspective, the transfer of compulsory retirement fund capital into a living annuity is generally tax-neutral, whereas the income drawn from the annuity is taxable in the hands of the annuitant. Practically, tax is normally withheld by the product provider through PAYE, although the correct liability depends on the retiree’s total taxable income from all sources. In the event of the annuitant’s death, the remaining capital can generally be paid to nominated beneficiaries, who may have the option to receive a lump sum, continue with an annuity, or use a combination of both, depending on the product rules and tax consequences. As such, beneficiary nominations should be reviewed regularly.

Plan before you retire

The biggest mistake we encounter is when retirees wait until formal retirement to understand how these rules work, at which point many decisions become urgent, such as how much cash to take, which annuity to choose, how much income to draw, how to invest the capital, and how to manage tax and liquidity. Ideally, the years before retirement should be used to understand the annuitisation rules, stress-test drawdown rates, review debt, build discretionary liquidity and decide how retirement fund capital will fit into the broader financial plan. Used well, a living annuity can form the backbone of a flexible retirement income plan. Used carelessly, it can place a retiree’s future income under unnecessary pressure.

Have a super day.

Sue

Taking cash at retirement is not a one-size-fits-all decision. Before choosing a lump sum, retirees should consider fund rules, previous withdrawals, tax, debt, future expenses, available investments, income needs, health, longevity, housing and whether the money has a defined purpose.

Explore other valuable insights