We recently overheard a retiree proclaiming he routinely advises friends and family to take the full one-third cash withdrawal when they retire. The advice is no doubt well-intentioned, but it reflects one of the more persistent problems in retirement planning: a rule describing what may be permitted is treated as though it prescribes what everyone should do.
In many retirement structures, members may take a portion of their benefit as cash and must use the balance to provide an income, although the amount available depends on the fund, the member’s vested rights and the components in which the money is held. Under the two-pot system, the retirement component is generally preserved for annuitisation, the savings component may be taken in cash at retirement, and older vested benefits may be governed by different rules. The familiar one-third rule is therefore useful shorthand, but it is neither universal nor sufficiently nuanced to constitute financial advice.
More importantly, the fact that a retiree may take cash does not mean that they should. Every rand withdrawn is a rand no longer available to generate retirement income, which is why we believe retirees should consider at least the following ten factors before making this generally irreversible decision.
1. What are you actually entitled to take?
The starting point is the structure of the retirement benefit itself. Pension, provident, preservation and retirement annuity benefits may include vested, savings and retirement components, together with protected rights accumulated under earlier legislation. Depending on the member’s history, more or less than one-third may be available in cash, while certain amounts must be annuitised. Ideally, an accurate breakdown from the fund should be requested.
2. Have you made previous withdrawals?
Retirement lump-sum tax is calculated cumulatively, meaning that previous taxable withdrawals, retirement lump sums and certain severance benefits are considered when SARS calculates the tax payable on the current benefit. Someone who withdrew money when changing jobs may therefore have used some of the lower tax bands years before retirement. The relevant figure is not the gross cash available, but the net amount remaining after tax.
3. How much debt do you carry?
Using cash to settle expensive debt can make sense where repayments would otherwise place pressure on retirement income. Eliminating credit card balances, personal loans or vehicle finance may materially improve monthly cash flow, but debt should not be settled automatically without comparing the interest saved with the income and growth the withdrawn capital could have produced. Paying off a manageable low-interest bond may feel reassuring while materially weakening long-term income.
4. Do you have immediate capital expenses?
Retirement often coincides with replacing a vehicle, renovating a home, funding a move, travelling, assisting children or paying medical expenses. These costs should be quantified before the retirement instruction is submitted. A planned withdrawal may prevent the retiree from incurring debt or selling investments at an inconvenient time, but a vague intention to ‘keep some money aside’ does not justify withdrawing a large lump sum.
5. What expenditure can you foresee later?
The planning horizon should extend beyond the first year. A roof may need replacing, a vehicle will eventually reach the end of its useful life, or a home may need to be adapted for reduced mobility. The objective is not to predict every expense, but to identify foreseeable capital requirements and decide which pool of money should fund them.
6. What discretionary investments do you have?
A retiree with substantial unit trusts, cash reserves, tax-free investments or other accessible assets may have little reason to remove more money from the retirement environment. Conversely, someone whose entire wealth is held inside retirement funds may need a carefully calculated reserve. The decision must be made across the whole balance sheet, rather than by viewing the retirement fund in isolation.
7. How much income do you need?
The lump sum and future income are two sides of the same decision. Before taking cash, the retiree should model the income that the remaining capital can support after allowing for fees, tax, inflation, investment returns and longevity. Where the income plan is already tight, maximising the cash withdrawal can turn a manageable retirement into one requiring increasingly aggressive drawdowns later.
8. What is your health and longevity outlook?
Poor health may justify greater access to capital where there are immediate medical needs or a shortened life expectancy. Equally, good health, family longevity and the possibility of living into one’s nineties strengthen the case for preserving income-producing capital. The plan should also consider the future cost of frail care, home-based care, medical aid and expenses not covered by a medical scheme.
9. Where and how will you live?
Housing decisions can radically alter the appropriate cash amount. A retiree who plans to downsize may realise capital later, while someone emigrating, moving to a retirement village or buying a life right may need significant cash upfront. Location also affects living costs, transport, healthcare access and family support, which is why the withdrawal should follow a considered housing strategy rather than precede it.
10. What is the money for, and can you protect it?
A defined purpose supported by a written plan is very different from withdrawing money because it feels safer in a bank account or because friends have done the same. Once retirement capital becomes accessible cash, it is easier to spend, lend to family, invest speculatively or absorb into everyday costs. The decision must therefore consider the needs of a spouse, family responsibilities, estate planning intentions and the retiree’s relationship with money.
There is no inherently correct percentage to take at retirement. For one person, the maximum cash amount may settle costly debt, fund a planned relocation and still leave sufficient capital to provide sustainable income. For another, the same decision may trigger unnecessary tax, weaken future income and create a pool of cash for which there is no genuine purpose.
Retirement planning is not improved by universal rules passed between friends, however confidently they may be expressed. The correct cash amount is the amount that supports the retiree’s income, liquidity, housing, health, tax and estate planning needs as part of one integrated strategy — and that may be the full permissible withdrawal, considerably less, or nothing at all.
Have a great day.
Sue